Ayurveda vs. Modern Medicine for Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a severe type of muscular dystrophy that leads to muscle weakness. Initially, muscle loss occurs in the thighs and pelvis, extending to the arms. The patients have difficulty standing, and by the age of 12, most of them are unable to walk. DMD is a genetic disease that occurs due to a mutation in the dystrophin gene. This causes excessive muscular fat production that makes muscles appear larger than usual. Muscle weakness is the main symptom of DMD. It can start as early as age 2 or 3 and affect the proximal muscles (those closest to the core of the body) before progressing to the distal limb muscles. Lower external muscles are typically afflicted first, followed by upper external muscles. The affected child may have trouble jumping, running, or walking.

There is no direct recognition of DMD in Ayurveda, but based on the progression and symptoms of the disease, it is explained through the concept of adibalapravritta vyadhi (inherited diseases). This leads to shukra-shonita dosha vyadhi (gametes disorder) and bijabhagavayay dushtijanya vyadhi (a genetic disorder). The progression of DMD is explained in both- modern and Ayurvedic medicine. Hence, it becomes important to note which medicinal system is effective in treating DMD. In this blog, we shall closely review how both the medicinal system understands the disease and its treatment approach.

Ayurvedic and modern medicine understanding of DMD

The understanding of Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD) in Ayurveda and modern medicine differs significantly due to their distinct philosophical frameworks and approaches to health and disease. Here is a comparative overview of how each system understands DMD:

 

Ayurvedic understanding of DMD

Modern medicine understanding of DMD

Philosophical basis

Dosha Imbalance: DMD is primarily seen as a disorder resulting from an imbalance of the doshas, especially Vata, which governs movement and neurological functions.

 

Dhatu (Tissue) Weakness: Ayurveda views muscle (Mamsa dhatu) degeneration in DMD as a weakness or depletion of the dhatus, which are the bodily tissues.

 

Agni (Digestive Fire): An impaired digestive fire can lead to the formation of ama (toxins), which disrupt normal bodily functions and contribute to disease progression.

 

Prakriti and Vikriti: The individual’s constitution (Prakriti) and current state of imbalance (Vikriti) are crucial in understanding the disease’s manifestation and progression.

Genetic Disorder: DMD is recognized as a genetic disorder caused by mutations in the DMD gene, which encodes the protein dystrophin.

 

Molecular and Cellular Pathology: Focuses on the molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying muscle degeneration.

Etiology and pathogenesis

Genetic and Hereditary Factors: Although not explicitly detailed in classical texts, Ayurveda acknowledges hereditary factors (Beeja dosha) that may predispose individuals to certain conditions.

 

Lifestyle and Diet: Poor dietary habits, a sedentary lifestyle, and stress are seen as contributing factors that can aggravate dosha imbalance and muscle degeneration.

 

Accumulation of Toxins: The buildup of Ama can obstruct the channels (Srotas) and disrupt nutrient supply to muscles, leading to their degeneration.

Genetic Mutation: Mutations in the dystrophin gene result in the absence or severe reduction of dystrophin protein, crucial for muscle fiber stability.

 

Muscle Fiber Damage: Without dystrophin, muscle fibers are more susceptible to damage during contraction and relaxation, leading to progressive muscle degeneration.

 

Inflammation and Fibrosis: Chronic muscle damage triggers inflammation and fibrosis, further exacerbating muscle weakness and loss of function.

Clinical features

Muscle Weakness and Atrophy: Seen as a manifestation of depleted Mamsa dhatu and aggravated Vata.

 

Fatigue and Weakness: result from poor nourishment and impaired metabolic processes.

 

Loss of Function: Progressive loss of muscle function due to continuous dosha imbalance and dhatu depletion.

Early Onset: Symptoms typically appear in early childhood, between ages 2 and 5.

 

Progressive Muscle Weakness: Begins in the proximal muscles (hips, thighs, shoulders) and progresses to the distal muscles.

 

Gait abnormalities: difficulty walking, frequent falls, and eventual loss of ambulation.

 

Cardiopulmonary Complications: The heart and respiratory muscles are also affected, leading to serious complications.

 

Shortened Lifespan: Advances in medical care have extended life expectancy, but it is still significantly reduced compared to the general population.

Ayurvedic and modern medicine treatments for DMD

The treatment approaches for Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD) in Ayurveda and modern medicine differ significantly due to their underlying philosophies and methodologies.

Ayurvedic treatment for DMD

The goal of ayurvedic treatment for DMD is

  1. To balance the doshas and enhance overall well-being.
  2. To strengthen muscles and support nerve function.
  3. To reduce inflammation and detoxify the body.
  4. To provide a holistic approach to improving quality of life.

To achieve that, Ayurveda focuses on enhancing overall vitality through natural remedies, lifestyle changes, and diet. Below are the therapies that are suggested to treat DMD.

 

1. Panchakarma (detoxification):

  • Virechana (purgation): To cleanse the body of accumulated toxins (Ama).
  • Basti (enema): Particularly vata-pacifying enemas to support nervous system function and muscle health.

 

2. Supportive therapies:

  • Abhyanga (oil massage): With medicated oils to improve circulation and muscle relaxation.
  • Swedana (sudation): Steam therapy to enhance detoxification and muscle relaxation.
  • Nasya (nasal administration): Medicated oils administered through the nose to support neurological function.

 

3. Yoga and pranayama:

  • Yoga: Gentle yoga postures to maintain flexibility, improve circulation, and support muscle function.
  • Pranayama: Breathing exercises to enhance respiratory function and overall vitality.

 

4. Herbal remedies:

  • Ashwagandha: Known for its muscle-strengthening and rejuvenating properties.
  • Guggulu: Helps reduce inflammation and supports muscle health.
  • Turmeric: Has anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties.

Modern medicine treatments for DMD

The goal of modern medicine’s treatments for DMD is

  1. To slow the progression of muscle degeneration.
  2. To manage symptoms and improve muscle function.
  3. To address complications and enhance the quality of life.
  4. To explore and develop potential curative therapies.

To achieve that, modern medicine focuses on managing symptoms, slowing disease progression, and addressing complications through evidence-based treatments and advanced technologies. Below are the treatment modalities employed in modern medicine to treat DMD.

  1. Medications:
  • Corticosteroids: Prednisone and deflazacort slow muscle degeneration and improve muscle strength.
  • Cardiac medications: ACE inhibitors and beta-blockers to manage heart complications.
  • Respiratory Support: Medications and devices to support respiratory function.
  1. Physical therapy:
  • Exercise Regimens: Tailored exercises to maintain muscle strength and flexibility.
  • Stretching: To prevent contractures and maintain range of motion.
  • Occupational Therapy: To support daily activities and enhance independence.
  1. Surgical interventions:
  • Spinal surgery: To correct scoliosis.
  • Tendon Release Surgery: To address contractures and improve mobility.
  1. Assistive devices:
  • Braces and orthotics: To support mobility and posture.
  • Wheelchairs: Customized to enhance mobility and comfort.

An Integrated Approach…

Combining Ayurvedic and modern medical treatments can provide a comprehensive approach to managing DMD:

  • Diet and Herbal Support (Ayurveda): Complement modern nutritional support and medications.
  • Detoxification and Rejuvenation (Ayurveda): Enhance overall vitality and support physical therapy.
  • Physical and Respiratory Therapies (Modern Medicine): Supported by Ayurvedic practices like yoga and pranayama.
  • Advanced Medical Treatments (Modern Medicine): Enhanced by the holistic and preventive approach of Ayurveda.

By integrating both systems, patients may benefit from a more personalized, holistic approach that addresses both immediate medical needs and long-term well-being.